The Chronicle of Evidence-Based Mentoring
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • Home
  • Editor’s Blog
  • Contributors’ Blog
  • Research
  • Practice
  • Profiles
  • News
  • Webinars
  • SUBSCRIBE
  • Search
  • Menu Menu

The power of many: Why schools are embracing broader formal and informal mentoring networks

April 19, 2016/0 Comments/in Mentoring in the News /by Justin Preston
http://traffic.libsyn.com/mentoringu/The_Power_of_Many.m4a

Podcast: Play in new window | Download

Group People Silhouette Gathering Sunrise Concept

Written by Alyza Sebenius, The Atlantic

In her job as a “dream director,” Jessica Valoris is tasked with unleashing the potential of disadvantaged students at an inner-city high school in Washington, D.C. Her employer, a New York-based nonprofit called The Future Project, embeds mentors like Valoris in public schools, characterizing her role as a “midwife of dreams” and “warrior of possibility.”

Serious risks like homelessness, suspension, early parenthood, and a lack of academic confidence threaten to derail poor, young Americans on their path toward high-school graduation. Yet stories like this one, and a growing body of research—including a study last year by America’s Promise Alliance, which found that students with social support are more likely to re-engage with school in the face of adversity—suggest that the United States should invest broadly in mentorship.

“Just as the federal government can see something like health care as a basic need, mentoring should be that, too,” said David Shapiro, the CEO of The National Mentoring Partnership, a founding partner of America’s Promise Alliance that, among other things, advocates for federal funding. “Having consistent support, outside home is essential.” Experts emphasize that mentorship entails much more than offering compassion to a child; mentors serve a range of needs, from ensuring access to food and other basic resources to setting academic expectations. But how scalable are its current models?

Formal mentorship is currently supported by philanthropy and federal agencies including the Office of Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention and the Corporation for National and Community Service. In the fiscal year 2015, OJJDP granted $90 million to mentoring organizations to support at-risk youth across the country—a sum sufficient to cover hundreds of thousands of students but not sufficient for need, according to Shapiro.

But other limitations, beyond funding challenges, make it difficult to expand such programs. For one, mentorship programs aren’t always effective. (In some cases they can even prove harmful, particularly when it comes to mentoring relationships that terminate prematurely.) For another, a prevailing thread among education experts today is that a single mentor isn’t sufficient. “We’re too enamored with the idea of the heroic volunteer who swoops in,” said Marc Freedman, the author of the influential 1999 book, The Kindness of Strangers: Adult Mentors, Urban Youth, and the New Volunteerism.

 

Indeed, education experts and nonprofits are embracing the idea that a broad web of formal and informal mentors is key to successfully serving young people. “This changes the conversation from ‘You have to be everyone to someone,’ to ‘You have to be someone to everyone,’” said Jonathan Zaff, the executive director of the Center for Promise, echoing an argument recently put forth by the Harvard political scientist Robert Putnam in his book Our Kids: The American Dream in Crisis. In an email, Putnam, who in his book notes that privileged youth are two to three times more likely to have an informal mentor outside of their family, said that “kids from working-class homes need more caring adults in their lives.” Disadvantaged students, he said, often lack access to the range of role models available to their more privileged peers—such as coaches, clergy, neighbors, or family friends. Absent these advisors, underprivileged students may be deprived of the kinds of information necessary for navigating and thriving in large institutions like colleges—for exercising what Putnam described as “savvy.”

Mandy Savitz-Romer, a senior lecturer at Harvard’s Graduate School of Education, cited a difference in perceptions of the future between privileged students and their counterparts, many of whom are at a major disadvantage because they do not believe they are “post-secondary material.” Adults, she observed, need to help underprivileged students believe that they can go to college. “The idea that you have a future in higher education does not exist,” she said of some communities.

Mentors are just one form of role models on campus that can shape student outcomes. School counselors represent another tier of non-teacher adults who can make a large difference for students: A 2013 study correlated the addition of a single guidance counselor at a given school with a 10 percentage point increase in four-year-college-going rates at the school. Still, like mentorship programs, school counseling suffers from limited funding.

And differences in resources for such services—access to private counselors or private schools with smaller counseling ratios among advantaged students—can further perpetuate inequality. “This is contradictory to the fundamental idea that education ought to be the source of social mobility,” said Christopher Avery, a professor of public policy and management at Harvard’s Kennedy School and an expert on college admissions.

A guidance counselor in an average American school is responsible for over 470 students, significantly higher than the 250-student maximum recommended by The American School Counselor Association. (California is home to some of the highest ratios, with 945 students per counselor on average.) A 2009 study revealed that the median ratio at public high schools was roughly three times that at private ones. These ratios suggest there is little interaction between counselors and their students in public schools, and because students with extreme situations (such as legal or health problems) can demand significant attention and disproportionately crowd out a counselor’s schedule, the amount of one-on-one time available to students is often extremely inconsistent.

Meanwhile, according to some educators, counselors shouldn’t focus strictly on getting kids into college. Nancy E. Hill, a professor at Harvard’s Graduate School of Education, suggested that although both college-bound students and their non-college-bound counterparts are under an incredible amount of stress to figure out their futures, the former get much more support than the latter. “Guidance programs largely focus on college, and students not focused on college feel left out,” she noted, suggesting another reason for increasing the staff and expertise in Guidance Departments. Valoris, the dream director, advocates customizing post-high-school plans to fit student needs, too, whether or not those needs include postsecondary education. “Personally I don’t think college is for everyone. We get pushed into going to college blindly, without a plan,” she said. Instead, she asks her students: “What is your dream for yourself and how will college support you in doing that?”

Other problems with the current system of high-school guidance counseling include a lack of sufficient counselor training related to college access and success—an issue raised by Michelle Obama’s Reach Higher Initiative—and the de-prioritization of guidance counselors’ time and responsibilities. “‘School counselor’ is currently a catch-all for a lot of different responsibilities,” said Lindsay Page, a professor at the University of Pittsburgh’s School of Education. She described responsibilities ranging from course scheduling, crisis management, and discipline to college counseling and recommendation writing. Sometimes counselors are even asked to take on tasks far outside their job description, such as substitute teaching and even lunchroom monitoring. “Schools require better articulation and protection of the roles that counselors play,” she said.

Savitz-Romer, the education lecturer at Harvard, advocates for training principals to better utilize their counselors, in part by explicitly evaluating school performance based on student outcomes—and not simply based on tests, but on postsecondary plans. “Schools are primarily seen as places of academic instruction,” she said. “The more we hold schools accountable for postsecondary outcomes, the more they will work on their own systems of preparation.” She envisions a world in which every high school has a post-secondary leadership team, one with the same resources as instructional teams.
To see the original article as well as a short video documentary, please click here.

Related posts:

Donors bet big on paid mentoring: Does it work? Mentors helping students prepare for college: More than just making the grade A Novel Program Provides an Entire Network of Support for At-Risk Youth Leaving So Soon? Researchers Investigate Why Mentoring Matches End Early
Tags: academic mentoring, adolescence, adolescents, at-risk youth, formal mentoring, higher education, implications for youth mentoring, improving mentoring programs, natural mentors, positive youth development, school-based mentoring, underrepresented populations, underserved populations, youth mentoring, youth mentoring research
Share this entry
  • Share on Facebook
  • Share on Twitter
  • Share on WhatsApp
  • Share on Pinterest
  • Share on LinkedIn
  • Share on Tumblr
  • Share on Vk
  • Share on Reddit
  • Share by Mail
https://www.evidencebasedmentoring.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/04/bigstock-Group-People-Silhouette-Gather-102528851_banner.jpg 360 960 Justin Preston https://www.evidencebasedmentoring.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/08/chronicle-logo-1.png Justin Preston2016-04-19 15:33:342018-09-17 10:57:43The power of many: Why schools are embracing broader formal and informal mentoring networks
You might also like
Big Brothers Big Sisters’ CEO Shares How the Nonprofit’s Model Stands the Test of Time
Online interventions can ease teen depression
When Mentoring First-Generation College Students, It Is The Little Things That Make The Difference
Mentors can be helpful during college transition period for young adults, research shows
The importance of the closure process in formal mentoring relationships
The impact and experiences of Campus Connections Aotearoa | Tūhono Aiopīpī youth mentees and university student practitioners: Quantitative evaluation report 2017–2019. University of Auckland
Will I be able to understand my mentee?: Examining the potential risk of the dominant culture mentoring marginalized youth
Difficult mentee? He or she may be struggling with borderline personality disorder

Editor’s Blog

  • Mentoring + supportive accountability = game changerJune 7, 2022 -

Worth Another Look

  • On Methods: What’s the difference between qualitative and quantitative approaches?October 13, 2021 -
  • The road ahead: The promise of task shifting, stepped care, and paraprofessional mentoringAugust 18, 2021 -
  • The top 25 mentoring movies of all time!July 12, 2021 -
  • Are supportive relationships enough? The great debate continuesApril 18, 2021 -
  • To disclose or not to disclose?October 23, 2020 -

Follow Us On Twitter

Many Black adolescents are treated unfairly by school staff in ways that negatively affect their school engagement & trust towards adults. Learn about how unfair treatments from school staff occur and how they, in turn, affect Black adolescents. evidencebasedmentoring.org/ho… pic.twitter.com/62FuZ3YBQw

About 5 months ago from Center for Evidence-Based Mentoring's Twitter via LaterMedia

Although Chilean higher education systems helped advance social mobility, it presents new challenges for students who might not have the skills necessary to succeed. Read about the impact of a peer-mentoring program on Chilean students’ academics. evidencebasedmentoring.org/th… pic.twitter.com/K1txAuyctB

About 5 months ago from Center for Evidence-Based Mentoring's Twitter via LaterMedia

Youth relationships with non-parental adults play an important role in youth development. Learn about the associations between youth perceptions of school, youth traits, classroom interactions, & quality of teacher-student relationships. evidencebasedmentoring.org/fi… pic.twitter.com/p8A48V1w4w

About 6 months ago from Center for Evidence-Based Mentoring's Twitter via LaterMedia

The COVID-19 pandemic has drastically altered students’ lives in school. Read about the challenges students faced during the early phases of the pandemic, & what specific factors can help protect them from experiencing adverse mental health symptoms. evidencebasedmentoring.org/st… pic.twitter.com/xBziDgKefj

About 6 months ago from Center for Evidence-Based Mentoring's Twitter via LaterMedia

Every other week a newsletter is sent out containing a new article written by Dr. Jean Rhodes, as well as other important articles related to mentoring. Sign up for our newsletter by visiting our website at the link below. evidencebasedmentoring.org/su… pic.twitter.com/ekwvDgiLXa

About 6 months ago from Center for Evidence-Based Mentoring's Twitter via LaterMedia

like us on facebook

Topics of Interest

academic mentoring (54) adolescence (115) adolescent development (144) adolescents (88) at-risk youth (240) big brothers big sisters (49) children (65) COVID-19 (123) Editor's Corner (58) education (64) emerging adulthood (64) formal mentoring (105) high-risk youth (100) implications for mentoring (46) implications for youth mentoring (132) improving mentoring programs (109) mental health (123) Mentor (92) mentor/mentee relationship (49) mentor/mentee relationships (68) mentoring (669) mentoring in the news (71) mentoring relationships (350) mentoring research (72) mentor roles (60) mentor training (59) natural mentoring (95) natural mentors (47) New Mentoring Research (57) positive youth development (224) practice (61) profiles in mentoring (46) research (214) research from related fields (54) school-based mentoring (79) supportive relationships (83) training (43) underrepresented populations (92) underserved populations (119) volunteering (51) webinar (43) well-being (50) youth (266) youth mentoring (404) youth mentoring research (84)

Sponsors

  • AlongAlongMarch 30, 2022 -

    In support of our continued conversation on how to support today’s youth, this issue of the Chronicle of Evidence-Based Mentoring is proudly sponsored by Along, a free digital tool designed to support educators to build developmental relationships with their students in easy and fun ways. Related posts: Academic Web Pages MENTOR: The National Mentoring Partnership

  • National Mentoring PartnershipMENTOR: The National Mentoring PartnershipNovember 12, 2014 -

    MENTOR: The National Mentoring Partnership (MENTOR) is the unifying champion for expanding quality youth mentoring relationships in the United States. For nearly 25 years, MENTOR has served the mentoring field by providing a public voice, developing and delivering resources to mentoring programs nationwide and promoting quality for mentoring through standards, cutting-edge research and state of the art tools.

  • Academic Web PagesAugust 6, 2012 -

    Academic Web Pages is the leading provider of customized websites for researchers, centers, nonprofits, and universities. AWP designed and has contributed generously to the creation of the Chronicle of Evidence-Based Mentoring.

Instagram

No images available at the moment

Follow Us!
Older and Wiser
The Chronicle of Evidence-Based Mentoring. All rights reserved. Site By Academic Web Pages.
  • Home
  • Editor’s Blog
  • Contributors’ Blog
  • Research
  • Practice
  • Profiles
  • News
  • Webinars
  • SUBSCRIBE
Scroll to top