New Study Shows How Mentors Can Promote Belonging in College

By Jean Rhodes

What happens to students’ mentoring relationships after they arrive on campus? In a new study, Aaliyah Anderson, Noelle Hurd, and their colleagues followed 340 underrepresented students at a predominantly White university, asking about their natural mentoring relationships throughout college and assessing their highest completed degree six years after their senior year (Anderson et al., 2026). Students who consistently had a larger network of mentors attained higher levels of education than those who had few mentors throughout college or whose initially larger networks declined sharply after they enrolled. Having more faculty and staff mentors, receiving more support across the college years, and retaining more mentors across multiple surveys were also associated with higher educational attainment (Anderson et al., 2026).

The findings raise questions about how colleges can help students sustain and develop these relationships, beginning in their first year. In a longitudinal study led by Matt Hagler, we followed 176 first-generation students through their first year at a predominantly minority-serving commuter university (Hagler et al., 2024). Support from precollege mentors who remained in students’ lives was associated with greater confidence in their ability to manage college, while support from newly acquired mentors was associated with a stronger sense of school membership. These findings suggest that the relationships students bring with them and those they develop on campus may serve different purposes during the transition to college (Hagler et al., 2024).

These connections develop at a time when many students are wondering whether they will be accepted, valued, or ever fit in, a concern that Walton and Cohen (2007) described as belonging uncertainty. Belonging is associated with a range of outcomes that matter to students and colleges. A 2025 meta-analysis of 26 studies found that university belonging was associated with better academic outcomes and well-being, with average correlations of .20 and .40, respectively (van Kessel et al., 2025). Students who perceived their peers as more inclusive also reported a stronger sense of belonging, with a stronger association among students of color (Redd & Brauer, 2026).

Together, these studies suggest that colleges should pay closer attention to how students’ networks develop over time. The mentoring studies do not establish that these relationships caused better outcomes, but they offer reasons to support both continuity and new connections. A former teacher, a supervisor at work, or a family friend might remain an important source of support as students get to know faculty and staff. Mentoring programs could make these relationships part of their conversations with students, asking whom they already rely on, how they might stay connected, and whom they would like to get to know on campus. Colleges, in turn, could give students and faculty more opportunities for repeated contact through courses, research projects, and other shared activities.