Huddle Up: New Study Highlights Links Between Sports Participation and Mental Health Outcomes for U.S. Adolescents

Hoffmann, M. D., Barnes, J. D., Tremblay, M. S., & Guerrero, M. D. (2022). Associations between organized sport participation and mental health difficulties: Data from over 11,000 US children and adolescents. PLOS ONE, 17(6), e0268583.

Introduction

The World Health Organization identifies mental health as a significant predictor of global disability, with childhood and adolescence marking vulnerable periods. Organized youth sports are suggested as protective, fostering well-being and resilience. However, the relationship is not universally positive—individual sports have sometimes been linked to adverse outcomes such as stress and anxiety. Hoffmann and colleagues (2022) aim to clarify these associations using recent, representative data from the Adolescent Brain Cognitive Development (ABCD) study, hypothesizing that team sports are more strongly associated with positive mental health outcomes than individual sports.

Methods

The researchers used data from 11,235 U.S. children aged 9 to 13 years participating in the ABCD study. Organized sports participation was categorized into team sports, individual sports, both types, or no sports. Parent-reported mental health data, measured using the Child Behavior Checklist (CBCL), encompassed emotional and behavioral syndromes such as anxiety, depression, and attention problems. Key covariates included age, sex, race/ethnicity, family income, and physical activity levels.

Data were analyzed using negative binomial regression models to account for the distribution of mental health scores.

Results

The findings demonstrate stark contrasts between types of sports participation. Team sports participation was consistently associated with lower mental health difficulty scores, including anxiety, depression, social and thought problems, and attention issues. For instance, team sports participants exhibited 19% lower withdrawn/depressed scores and 17% lower social problems scores compared to non-sport participants. Interestingly, team sports also reduced rule-breaking behaviors among females.

In contrast, participation in individual sports was linked to increased mental health difficulties. Individual sport participants showed 16% higher anxiety/depression scores and 14% higher attention problems scores compared to non-sport participants. Combined participation in team and individual sports generally yielded no significant differences compared to non-sport participants, except for a reduction in rule-breaking behavior among females.

Discussion

The study supports the notion that team sports are uniquely beneficial for youth mental health, fostering belongingness, resilience, and social skills, which are critical protective factors against mental health difficulties. The authors suggest that team environments create opportunities for youth to develop positive peer relationships and collective coping strategies, which may reduce stress and promote psychological well-being.

Conversely, individual sports appear to exacerbate mental health challenges, a finding that diverges from some previous research. The authors hypothesize that the heightened pressure and isolation inherent in individual sports may contribute to increased stress and self-criticism. These athletes often bear sole responsibility for their performance outcomes, which may amplify anxiety and negative self-perceptions. Additionally, body-focused sports like gymnastics or ballet may heighten vulnerability to social physique anxiety.

Implications for Mentoring Programs

The results underscore the critical role of structured team activities in promoting mental health among youth, offering actionable implications for mentoring programs. Mentors can use these findings to advocate for increased access to team sports, particularly in underserved communities. Programs should focus on inclusivity, ensuring that socioeconomic barriers do not preclude participation.

For individual sports participants, mentoring programs should incorporate mental health literacy to help youth develop coping mechanisms for sport-related stress. Mentors could collaborate with coaches to integrate mindfulness training and stress management techniques into training regimens. Additionally, they should remain attuned to signs of performance-related anxiety or social isolation among mentees in individual sports, providing timely support and referrals to mental health resources.

Read full article here